4.4 Case 3

In this case, we slightly make the time step longer than before. We start to see the instability of FTCS.

\(\tau =0.0013\) sec, \(h=0.1\ \)ft\(,\) \(\frac {u\tau }{h}=0.026\leq 1\) for fixed \(u\)

Speed Method CPU time (sec) RMSE Animation (2D) plots
U=2 Explicit FTCS 1.9 0.0494 HTML HTML
Explicit LAX 2.78 0.01125 HTML
Implicit FTCS 3.7 0.01245 HTML
C-R 3.9 0.01128 HTML
U=t/20 Explicit FTCS 2.0 0.00365 HTML HTML
Explicit LAX 2.9 0.00331 HTML
Implicit FTCS 5.56 0.00346 HTML
C-R 6 0.00331 HTML

For explicit FTCS, The solution now starting to show instability at 25 minutes. Lax remained stable since CFL is satisfied. Explicit FTCS is becoming less accurate as well. Explicit Lax is most accurate at this time step.