problem:
A fluid having density , specific heat
, and heat conductivity
, flows at a constant velocity
in a
cylindrical tube of length
, and radius
. The temperature at position
is
and diffusion of
heat is ignored. As it flows, heat is lost though the lateral side at a rate jointly proportional to
the area and to the difference between the temperature
of the external environment and the
temperature
of the fluid (Newton's law of cooling). Derive a PDE model for the temperature
Find the general solution of the equation by transforming to a moving coordinates system
Answer:
Term | Definition | Units (SI) |
heat
conductivity
| The quantity of heat that passes in unit time through unit area of a substance whose thickness is unity, when its opposite faces differ in temperature by one degree |
|
Specific heat
| the amount of heat needed to raise a unit mass by one degree. |
|
Density | density |
|
First we need to decide on the quantity over which we are applying the balance equation over. We solve this problem 2 times. The first by using the amount of heat as the quantity. Next we solve the problem by using the density of heat as the quantity.
Using amount of heat as the quantity to apply balance equation on
Apply the energy balance equation. Consider 2 cross sectional area at .
Total amount of heat inside this volume = mass of fluid inside this volume specific heat
its
temperature
Hence amount of heat between is
Now consider the rate that heat flows in/out the volume between and
, this is given
by
and since the area does not change, this is the same as
where is the amount of heat that flows though a unit area per unit time. (the Flux)
Now there is some heat loss due to cooling via the lateral side. Use Newton law of cooling which says that
the amount of heat a body loses per second is proportional to temperature difference between
it and its surrounding temperature, and proportional to the area of the body though which heat
is lost. The constant of proportionality is . The area of the body in this case is the surface of
the cylinder of strip of width
which is given by
when considering a differential
length.
Hence lateral heat loss rate between and
is
. The minus sign is
to say that this is considered to be a heat loss, not gain, into the volume under consideration. Now need to find
what the units of this
is (this is NOT the heat conductivity coefficient). Using dimensional analysis, we
write
=
So to obtain the energy balance we write
Move the differentiation inside and assuming constant density throughout
Now apply fundamental law of calculus to the flux term in the RHS we have
Changing the limits of integration on the RHS to make it match the LHS and canceling we
obtain
Because the above holds for all intervals of integration and the functions involved are continuous, then we can remove the integrals and just write
For flux, consider the advection model, hence where
is amount of heat per unit
volume at
, but this is the same as
, hence
since
is
constant, then the above becomes
Hence the PDE is
Let me check dimensionality. Each term above should have the same units.
has units
has units
has units
Hence the PDE is dimensionality correct. Now I have more confidence it is correct. Now we solve the same problem by using the density of heat.
Using density of amount of heat as the quantity to apply balance equation on
density of heat is , hence rate of change of density of heat is
For the flux term, using the advection model, we obtain that
Hence
Now for heat loss,
Hence the balance equation now becomes
Hence
Which matches the results obtained earlier.
Now complete the problem. Find a general solution.
Let Hence
and
Let , therefore
But from the PDE itself which we derived above, we see that Hence
Integrating over time we obtain
For an arbitrary function , Substituting back for
and
we obtain
Hence general solution is
The function can be found from initial conditions that specific
problem:
Prove that if the Dirchlet problem
has nontrivial solution then the constant must be positive.
solution:
Using Green first identity,
Let in the above
But since
on
, hence
Now from the PDE itself, hence the above becomes
The integral in the RHS is
Consider the case if the integral in the RHS is zero. This implies that . But
is a norm
of a vector. (this vector being the gradient of the scalar field function
). The only way for
a norm of a vector to be zero is for the vector itself to be zero. For example, look at
,
Since this sum is zero, and we are adding nonnegative
numbers, then this means
,
. This implies that
itself is either zero everywhere, or
is not
zero, but
, i.e.
is a constant function w.r.t to each of its independent variables. But we can't use the
case when
everywhere since we are looking for nontrivial solution, hence the other possibility is for
is a constant function w.r.t to each of its independent variables. But this case also fails, because we
are told
on
, and so if it is constant, this means it is zero also everywhere inside
which means the trivial solution again, which we do not like. Hence we conclude that
can
NOT be zero. Hence only other option is for it to be strictly positive, i.e.
must be
Hence , where
. But since
is not zero, then
, hence
is strictly positive
question:
solution:
Part(a)
Apply balance equation. Using the volume density of the material as the quantity to conserve. There is no
loss in this problem, hence
Hence
Now the flux is made up of 2 parts in this problem, due to advection and due to diffusion. Hence
Where the minus sign next to the advection term is due to speed being in opposite direction to the x-axis. Hence the PDE is
Part(b)
At steady state, , hence we obtain
We can solve this by separation of variables. Let
Let Since
Hence
We consider that at , (i.e. since very deep lake, we take
very large)
Then
We also know that , hence
Hence
Hence the solution is
Then
To verify, as we obtain
and at
Note, it does not seem to make too much sense to me that in any tube length, total amount is always ,
for this implies, for some length
that
but
Hence which means
or
, which means
which at
blows up. So this means
, i.e.
must be
.